[文章]：Allplan, Revit and ArchiCAD

jiaoyanbing · 发表于 2005-3-16 11:10:20

马上注册，结交更多好友，享用更多功能，让你轻松玩转社区。

您需要登录才可以下载或查看，没有账号？立即注册

×

The battle seems to be among Allplan, Revit and ArchiCAD. Following the scheme: "Mine is the best!", you guess which is the best software for any respective side. In general, those Allplan guys appear to be equally unware of Revit as this forum's Revit users of Allplan, arguments such as ".....That left Revit and Allplan. Being an experienced user of AutoCAD, I initially felt that Revit would be the package for us, as it is produced by Autodesk. However, having tried the demo, we noticed that whilst this package was easy to user, I remember telling my boss that it was a drawing package for dummies, it too lacked the depth we required from a package......"...... lack the objectiveness of an argument and tend to be more of a prejudice.....well, as an ADT user who's not decided on any of the above three, it is a gambling situation,.....and my bet is on Revit....

tomcat176 · 发表于 2005-3-16 17:58:22

求求楼主，翻译一下？！
好不好？！你估计是XD里E文排行前10名的？！！！

supermale · 发表于 2005-3-16 19:04:21

楼主是外国人吧……

jolin · 发表于 2005-8-9 13:47:17

I bet on archicad for the coming maxon form and its huge numbers of plugins.And its built in lightworks rendering engine is much better than that of revit.

raveiy · 发表于 2005-8-9 16:20:07

唉！没用过Archicad,我就赌Revit了。其他什么都不学`

omnii · 发表于 2005-8-9 16:33:48

我们总是说，市场说明一切.好像中国人都在为渲染的功能强弱来定义一个三维软件的功能的强弱.也许是我们被目前的三维软件的应用给误导了.我要告诉大家,将来的三维软件不只用在建筑表现上,它是一种实在的高效的设计工具.不能只从光能传递等渲染效果上来看三维软件.

jolin · 发表于 2005-8-9 17:01:54

我这么说是因为在modeling上面archicad，revit乃至allplan基本上都差不多强，各有各的长处，而在rendering方面则ac要强得多，更何况还有artlantis ，lightscape等第三方软件的直接支持。不是说单单比较rendering，斑竹误会了。在maxonform以前ac和revit的modeling基本上在一个层次上，感觉rv的结构更严谨一些，在幕墙方面revit也更方便一些，而ac则相对比较友好。但是现在有了c4d的支持以后，在freeform甚至一般构件构筑上都要上好几个层次。现在ac和rv都在中国市场做推广，我想由于和大量欧洲事务所的合作会使ac更具有竞争的优势。

tomcat176 · 发表于 2005-8-9 22:32:24

RV的渲染绝对不会是问题,倒是楼上的freeform层次绝对是重点!!!

omnii · 发表于 2005-8-10 14:05:29

就像tom所说的,现在RV的渲染不再是问题.AC的渲染很强大,是因为它外加的渲染器十分丰富,而现在我们有一个非常好的消息,就是3dmax7之后的版本以及3d viz等都可以直接使用RV的模型.所以,渲染也不再限于RV的渲染器了.

jolin · 发表于 2005-8-10 15:35:41

拭目以待吧。

RUBING · 发表于 2005-8-10 18:24:03

我现在都很迷茫不知道是学REVIT还是学ARCHICAD好,两种都很好.

xjh · 发表于 2005-8-12 10:54:02

这些都不是重点,关键是把设计学好.不要为工具迷惘.

jiaoyanbing · 发表于 2005-8-14 00:40:32

THANKS!
I LOVE CHINA!
http://bbs.hxsd.com.cn/post/view ... 7&sty=1#6547727
连环画

greenhenry · 发表于 2005-8-23 19:13:15

试用了一下Allplan2005,遗憾的是里面的帮助文件无效.

pagemaker · 发表于 2005-8-23 22:31:38

I totally agree with jiaoyabin, choosing a tool just just like kind of gambling, but I still belive Autodesk and her Revit will not let me down, as you have been more familiar with Revit, you will in love with it eventually!
It's been really a long time I haven't post new article here: )

账号		自动登录	找回密码
密码			立即注册

[文章]：Allplan, Revit and ArchiCAD

马上注册，结交更多好友，享用更多功能，让你轻松玩转社区。

相关帖子

试用了一下Allplan2005,遗憾的是里面的帮助文件无效.